Archive for Fishing News
2011 Long Island Fishing Season Reviewed
Posted by: | CommentsAs we approach the start of 2012 I wanted to take a bit of time to review how the fishing season went down on the waters of the Great South Bay and Fire Island Inlet during the 2011 season. Before getting into this too far, I want to say Thank You once again to all the folks who sailed aboard the Maybe Tonight during the 2011 season and who played such a large part in making it such a GREAT year!!
Striped Bass fishing in the Spring and Fall was VERY good. The Spring bluefish action was very nice as well but the larger fish were not around in the numbers we are used to until almost summer-time.Speaking of summer, fluke fishing in the area was EXCELLENT both in the bay and the ocean waters. The Fall brought us some nice striper action both day and night. Mild temperatures had the fish in the area right up to the closing bell on December 15th. Let’s take a closer look at how the season went aboard my boat.
The 2011 season started for the Maybe Tonight at the end of April when the boat was launched during a miserable, rainy, windy day for the ride to her slip in Seaborn Marina in Bay Shore NY. Little did we know at the time that the wind that day was going to be a harbinger of the winds we would endure for the majority of the season.
The end of April into May saw the flounder fishing actually providing some results for folks giving them an honest shot. While far from red-hot, the action was solid enough where you could actually feel as though you were going to catch a couple. Added to this was the surprise return of the blowfish to the Great South Bay waters. For many folks the blowfish outnumbered the flounders and this was a very welcome addition to the Spring fishery in the area.
By mid-May the bunker were settling into their normal locations in the Great South Bay and the striper fishermen were all over them with cast-nets flying to fill their live-wells with this prime striped bass bait. The stripers did not disappoint either as they put on quite a show in the Fire Island waters right into late July. Anglers drifting their live baits in the inlet or outside in the ocean around the large bunker schools were rewarded with numerous LARGE stripers with the action lasting for weeks.
As we moved into summer, there were still bunker schools in the ocean but now the bluefish had found them and were tearing them up making it very hard to find any stripers who remained in the area. Not a problem though as I love catching this saltwater alligators too!!!
Fluke fishing was also in full swing as summer moved in, the bottom of the Great South Bay seemed to be paved with the flatties. The downside here in the bay was that the vast majority of the fish were below the New York legal size limit.
Summer also brought with it the beach season and my wife and I took full advantage by making several trips to our favorite anchorages at Talisman Beach and the cove of the Sore Thumb. Sand, sun and surf were the rule of the day on these trips. Love it!!!
As we moved to the end of summer, the snapper bluefish were in solid numbers and these prime baits were put into use searching out some of the hard to find weakfish in the bay. While these fish are not around in good numbers in recent years, late summer generally gives us a shot at a few and I was happy to find them in early September on a few late afternoon trips.
Moving into October things began to pickup nicely as the weather began to cool. The bunker put in appearances in the Fire Island Inlet and Great South Bay again and the large bluefish were right on their tails. Good stripers were in the mix as well but the bluefish were tough to get through. By mid-month the bunker had moved back outside again and daytime action on the bass slowed. At the same time the night bite on live eels really started to shine and the boat had a great finish to October right through the middle of November fishing night tides with the eels.
The end of November had the large baits show up again inside, with bunker, shad and herring all appearing in decent numbers and the stripers blasting them in short order. While making bait was tough some days, you were almost guaranteed a fish per bait on the days you found the livies!!!
The fantastic jigging action we had in the ocean the past couple of years just never materialized this year along Fire Island area. Several exploratory trips made in the ocean along the beaches produced very little, with most days not even showing any marks on the finder. The schools of sandeels that had driven the action the last few years just did not show in any numbers this season. Even days where you did mark the baitfish, the gamefish were just not on them.
Here’s a video I threw together with some highlights of the 2011 season. I am already chomping at the bit to get on the water for 2012!!
Tight Lines.........
Capt Paul Mandella
captpaul@maybetonightcharters.com
Connect With Me On Facebook

Great South Bay Striped Bass on Live Eels
Posted by: | CommentsAfter cancelling my plans to fish the ocean outside Fire Island Inlet this morning due to MORE of the winds that have plagued the area the entire Fall I decided on an evening trip to drag some live eels around the Great South Bay.
I found my buddy Dennis willing to give it a go and we sailed off into the choppy bay right at sunset. We arrived for the start of the ebb current and made a bunch of drifts and moves around the inlet area with nothing to show for it.
I decided to try and find some lee behind the beach and it did not take long for Dennis to find the first fish of the night. This one turned out to be a short striper. I had a quick pickup on my eel but did not get hooked up.
I made another move back further into the bay and once again, it did not take long for Dennis to find another fish. First drop and BANG!! Shortly after a decent 17lb striper was on the deck. Still nothing for me and sadly that was how it would end up.
We called it a night as the current began to slow. Not a bad way to kill a few hours. I’m hoping for the weatherman to throw us a break and turn the FAN off. We’ll see what happens.
Tight Lines.........
Capt Paul Mandella
captpaul@maybetonightcharters.com
Connect With Me On Facebook

Long Island Fishing Report- Halloween Morning Striped Bass
Posted by: | CommentsI arrived at the Marina at 2am on Halloween morning with the thermometer reading 33 degrees and the boat covered in frost. This was my first trip since the historic Nor’Easter that hit Long Island over the weekend delivering the first snow of the season. Bundled up the thermal clothing and backed the boat out of the slip into a VERY still canal.
Arrived on scene for the start of the outgoing current and several drifts produced no life so I made a move to the Fire Island Inlet. Spent time drifting each of the rips inside the inlet with no results either. I did not notice any of the other boats doing anything either. I started to get worried about the storm’s impact on the stripers in the area.
The search continued with me making a move way back into the Great South Bay and found the fish right away. Not red hot action by any stretch but did manage 5 stripers in the teens before the sun came up and ended the action. One of the fish appeared to have suffered an attack in it’s younger days as he was missing a chunk out of his back. The wound was fully healed over and he appeared none the worse for it. All the stripers tonight were released back to enjoy their Halloweens.
Fun night on the water,
Tight Lines.........
Capt Paul Mandella
captpaul@maybetonightcharters.com
Connect With Me On Facebook

Islip Fire Department Annual Striped Bass Contest- Fire Island Fishing Fun
Posted by: | CommentsThe cooler nights are starting to get Long Island Striped Bass anglers in the spirit of the season. As water temps continue to drop the striper fishing in the Fire Island area is going to heat up.
Adding to the fun of the fall striped bass season are the almost weekly contests run on Long Island’s south shore during the fall. The first of these contests every year is the one run by the Islip Fire Department. These guys run a great event and they do a wonderful job of using the proceeds to benefit a local family in their service area.
We have fished this every year of it’s existence and always have a blast. Check them out at www.islipfd.org
Tight Lines.........
Capt Paul Mandella
captpaul@maybetonightcharters.com
Connect With Me On Facebook

Hurricane Irene Impacts Fire Island Area on Long Island’s South Shore
Posted by: | CommentsHurricane Irene rolled up the Eastern seaboard causing widespread damage along it’s entire path. The severe flooding, power outages, downed trees and damage to homes was something that has not been seen for a very long time, especially along the New Jersey and southern New York shorelines. I am writing this post from my perspective as a home and boat owner on Long Island and my dealings with Hurricane Irene.
With all the weather computer models pointing to a Long Island landfall during the weekend of 8/27 through 8/28 our preparations for the storm began back on the Tuesday prior. All outside patio and pool furniture was stored away. Shopping for enough supplies to carry us through a week was completed as well. With the house and surrounding property secured to the best of our ability my attention then turned to the boat.
A call to my marina, Seaborn Marina in Bay Shore NY, got me on the schedule to have the boat pulled and blocked in the yard as the forecast called for storm surges of 6-10 ft above normal. Combine this forecast with the fact that we were on a new moon and the expectation was that the Great South Bay waters would rise too high to keep the boat safely in her slip. The boat was securely blocked on Saturday morning in advance of Irene’s arrival. We completed some last minute tasks and then hunkered down and home hoping for the best.
I spent the majority of Saturday night watching several LARGE oak trees in our yard swaying back and forth in the building winds and praying they would stay upright. Thankfully, they did. Hurricane Irene made landfall Sunday morning on the extreme western end of Long Island and was technically labelled a Tropical Storm as she came ashore. Whatever they called it, the conditions were both amazing and fearful at the same time. Our neighborhood managed to maintain electric service through the worst of the storm and televised reports had sustained winds in the upwards of 65 mph across Long Island with locally higher gusts.
Despite all the news agencies advising against venturing out I could not stand thinking about how the boat had fared at the marina so off I went. Driving around trees and downed power lines gave me a chance to second guess this decision but I continued toward the boat. The major highways were wide open and the ride was easy taking it nice and slow with the heavy winds howling against my Dodge 2500 pickup.
Arriving in Bay Shore, the scene was like a tornado with trees down everywhere you looked. While turning into the marina I peeked down the street which ended at the Town marina and it was submerged. I could see folks walking through water up to their thighs. It was this side that had me most worried about how the boat made out.
I was VERY happy to see that while the water in my marina was to the top of the bulkhead, it was not spilling over any further than that. Walking through the maze of boats that had been stored I came to mine and was THRILLED to find her standing on the blocks just as she was left. What a relief this was!!! The howling winds had pretty much stripped the local trees of their leaves and the exterior and cockpit was littered with them but that was the extent my boat experienced. A quick peek around the yard showed every single boat was in great shape, and those that had elected to stay in the water all survived Hurricane Irene as well.
Did some preliminary cleanup on the boat before we headed back home. On the way back to our home we took a detour through our old neighborhood in Oakdale and Sayville and were amazed at how much more damage seemed to have occurred in this area. Sayville was reported to have had the highest recorded wind gust at just over 90 mph and looking around it was hard to debate that fact.
In Sayville village we turned down a few of the more scenic streets that all lead to the Great South Bay and found many of them flooded with deep water from the bay’s surge. I found a dry street and followed to the bay to catch some quick video. The following video was taken several hours after Hurricane Irene had made landfall but it was still apparent just how bad the storm had the bay torn up. On another street we saw one of the LARGE trees in this area had been toppled and cut a home almost in half. Terrible scene!!!
We arrived back home Sunday afternoon only to find the power had now gone out. I guess it was only fair after seeing the damage suffered by so many other Long Island residents. While it was still blowing pretty well we started the cleanup process which would continue for Monday as well.
By lunchtime on Monday we had the yard in decent shape and a call to the marina advised me that the boat was BACK in the water. My wife had some errands to do so I put off the rest of the yard work to take a trip to the boat for a good cleanup of all the debris. Once that was completed I could not resist the urge to take a short cruise to my favorite fishing area, Fire Island Inlet, for a peek at the effect of the storm.
A decent breeze was blowing from the southwest, leading to some infamous Great South Bay chop. Heading through the West Channel I found huge raft of eel-grass bundled up with a LOT of garbage. Garbage that was obviously from LAND. Bottles and plastic bags made up the bulk of it but there was plenty of other stuff that apparently had washed out of the yards and shorelines of the bay. I was happy to find all of the buoys in this stretch exactly where they should be.
My arrival at the Fire Island Inlet had my mouth opened as first thing I noticed were the red 8 and 10 buoys from the inlet way back up inside, well off station. Cruising past the Sore Thumb I was surprised to see just how well what is left of it had weathered the storm. Just west of the rocks on the Thumb I noticed a large cut in the beach a couple of feet deep. The beach appeared to have been breached by the over-wash running up behind the dunes and then feeding back to the ocean through a low spot in the beach.
I continued outside the inlet to the point where the red 6 buoy would normally be but it was NOT there. It had been dragged a 1/4 mile or so to the west ending up just off the Town of Bablyon Overlook beach. I also noticed the red 4 buoy was dragged north of it’s chart location and ending up almost where the 6 buoy should have been. I could not get close enough to the West Bar due to the large breakers still rolling across the inlet but it was very easy to see another two buoys up on the shoal with wave breaking over them. What a navigational mess for the Coast Guard.
I headed back to the marina an EXTREMELY happy boater. It was the day after the nastiest storm to hit Long Island in 26 years, the sun was out and I was on the water with the knowledge that my family all weathered the storm safely and our home was safe and sound.
In closing I would like to say that I read a lot on the online forums, Facebook and Twitter regarding people stating that this storm was an over-hyped, overblown media fiasco. It’s almost like they are disappointed we did not get hit with a storm in the class of Katrina. These folks should keep in mind the families who were not so lucky with THIS storm. Last I heard there were 11 deaths associated to Irene along the coast. Many homes were completely damaged to the point of being uninhabitable. I find it VERY hard to believe that those families who lost a loved one or a home are feeling that this storm was a OVERBLOWN fiasco. To them this storm was the MOST devasting storm ever!!!!!! Please REMEMBER THAT!!!!!
Tight Lines.........
Capt Paul Mandella
captpaul@maybetonightcharters.com
Connect With Me On Facebook

Long Layoff ENDS!! The Maybe Tonight is back in action
Posted by: | CommentsWell it has been WAY too long since I’ve had anything fishing/boating related to speak about. This, unfortunately due to the fact I experienced motor issues two weeks back. I am well aware that “stuff” happens but I have been very fortunate in my boating years and this marks the very first time I’ve had a boat out of order due to mechanical problems. I guess it could be said that I was overdue.
On the way across Great South Bay on June 26th I noticed the port-side motor just did not sound right. As I backed off the throttle the sound became even more evident. A very noticeable clicking/knocking noise. I can only describe it as sounding like a car engine that is VERY low on oil. I knew the oil was still new but double checked and found the level was fine.
My party did fish the rest of the day where they loaded up on short fluke to 19.5 inches. The return trip was a mess as I was forced to limp back across the bay on one motor during a VERY crowded boating weekend. Add in the fact that I had to disappoint 3 other parties slated for that afternoon and the next day. Not my fondest boating memory by any stretch.
Brought the boat to the mechanic and the first take was the powerhead was the issue. I left the boat with them for further investigation but was not feeling too optimistic about how long it would be down for.
On Friday July 8th I received somewhat good news from the yard that the powerhead was fine and the issue was related to the lower unit. With the green light given they replaced the unit over the weekend and gave the boat a good test run. She was given a clean bill of health and I rescued her from the yard on yesterday (July 12) afternoon.
I took a nice easy cruise across the bay and as my confidence in the repair grew I let her run. It was a RUSH having the boat behave as good as the day I got it. I needed to confirm everything further in my mind before having anyone else aboard so I headed out Fire Island Inlet in some sloppy conditions. VERY sloppy actually. Not a problem at all. All systems were GO!!!
I decided to fish some while I was out and found some of the bunker pods despite the big swell and chop kicked up by a 20kt west wind. Spent some time fishing the live bunker on a bunch of different schools but had no luck. I then headed back inside to fish some pieces in the bay and as I had expected the bluefish made very short work of the live bait.
Once the livewell was emptied I moved way back in the bay with the idea of bucktailing some fluke. This paid off pretty well as I grabbed a nice fluke that went 4lbs on the Boga on the very first drop. From there it was back to business as usual with the normal procession of one short after another. It did not matter to me one bit as I was back aboard the Maybe Tonight and we were FISHING again!!!
I would not be going on a limb to say it was a VERY long two week layoff but in the end all turned out as well as it could for a mechanical problem of the magnitude of a lower unit.
Tight Lines.........
Capt Paul Mandella
captpaul@maybetonightcharters.com
Connect With Me On Facebook




















